ISO, Grain, Transparency vs. Negative, Specialty Films
In todays world of digital cameras, a lot of you are probably looking at
this lesson and wondering exactly what the point is. I constantly argue
with my husband (who is NOT a photographer) about the future of film. He
says it is going the way of vinyl records, but I insist that film will
always be there for us, even though I shoot almost exclusively digital
today. Regardless of which of us is right, to ignore the history of film
and an understanding of how it works together with light would be a
mistake. So well go into a little lesson on the history of photography and
film in this lesson and then talk a bit about how this affects us in a
digital world. One thing to note is that while many professional printing
houses have moved to accept digital files, transparencies are still widely
accepted and preferred by a wide range of professional photographers and
printers, not to mention the folks who shoot black and white and enjoy that
time in the darkroom developing their own shots. Theres nothing quite like
it, and I think that will be here to stay forever.
|
|
|
Film - A History Of
Its Beginnings
It's difficult to imagine a world without photography. Photographs changed
the world in ways that we can barely imagine. We can now literally see things
that happen all the way across the world without ever leaving our home. We
can communicate visually with people who don't even speak our language. That
world without photography existed just 165 years ago. Before that, people
relied on paintings and verbal descriptions, which were entirely dependent on
conscious or subconscious alterations interjected by the people that used
these methods to communicate.
Prior to the creation of a successful photographic process, man was
fascinated with the idea of creating a photograph. Leonardo DaVinci made
drawings of plans for a basic camera as far back as 1519, but there was no
way to actually capture images that would last permanently using this tool.
Over the next several hundred years, many scientists noticed that forms of
silver, when exposed to light, would darken. That basic camera, called a
Camera Obscura, could be used to actually create images using this silver
solution, but there was no way to make the image permanent.
In 1827, a
man by the name of Nipce (pronounced Nee-ps) found a way to make a
light-sensitive silver solution harden. It required an exposure time of eight
hours or more, but this was actually the very first successful photograph.
Nipce called these Heliographs. He then went into a partnership with a man name
Daguerre. Nipce died shortly thereafter, but Daguerre kept working on the
photographic process and found a way to decrease exposure time to less than a
half hour, and also a way to use salt to make the images permanent. These
images formed positive 'prints' on metal plates. Daguerre called
his images Daguerreotypes and is largely credited today with discovering
photography.
This entire process caused QUITE a stir. (Daguerre's wife was about the only
person who was happy with his results, because she'd spent the last several
years thinking her husband was losing his mind working night and day on this
project.) People had never seen such images before with such detail and found
it kind of disturbing. Many called daguerreotypes blasphemy and the work of the
devil. Then there were the painters and artists who were terrified that
photography would overtake what they did for a living and feared that they
would have to find new professions. I find that last note of particular
interest because today I hear the same sort of thing from others in my
profession who have spent the last thirty or forty years shooting film and
are now daunted by digital photography and it's ease of use contributing to
the number of photographers growing by leaps and bounds.
I have seen daguerreotypes and they are truly beautiful and amazing, though
aside from the end process of capturing an image made of light and making it
permanent, the process is very different from any current photographic
technique used today. Further advancements that got us to the point where we
are today were: the ability to transfer these permanent images to paper
rather than metal plates; the ability to copy these images without having to
re-take the picture; the invention of celluloid film - then the invention of
COLOR celluloid film; motion picture photography and digital photography -
the latest step in the journey of advancements.
Okay,
But How Does Film Work?
So now we sort of have a history of where photography came from, but how does
film actually work? Let's talk about light for a minute.
There's something called the electromagnetic spectrum. It's composed of
everything from microwaves to radio waves and ultraviolet waves to infrared
waves. Somewhere in the middle of all of that is a tiny little section of
light waves that the human eye can see and interpret into different colors
from red to yellow to blue.
Light is really weird stuff. According to the physics books it's not REALLY a
wave but it's not REALLY a particle, either. It's made up of photons. People
who understand physics might be able to grasp the whole thing, but I'm going
to assume that since I don't understand exactly what photons are, you can
understand the basics of film without really knowing what they are, too. So
we're going to just go by faith that it's these photons that cause the
sensitive stuff on the film to make the picture you wind up with.
This 'sensitive stuff' is made up of gelatin and something called
silver-halide crystals. It's referred to as the 'emulsion' of the
film. These silver-halide crystals are what detect the photons that are
hitting the film and the gelatin holds it all together. When light hits them,
these little crystals cluster together into bunches, depending upon how much
light is hitting them, and when enough of them cluster together, you get a
dark spot on your film in the shape of whatever is in your image. In color
images, there are separate layers for red, green and blue that all have
little crystals working together to create a final product.
ISO
and Exposure
Now, in lesson two we talked about aperture and shutter speed and how they
affect exposure. Since you have that down, I'll introduce a third element
that we can throw in to further complicate the whole business. Your camera's
film has something called a 'speed', too. It's usually referred to
in units of ISO (which stands for the International Standards Organization)
and typically comes in the following speeds:
ISO 25 - Slowest Film
ISO 50
ISO 100
ISO 200
ISO 400
ISO 800, 1000 and 1600 - Fastest Films
The 'faster' the film is, the more quickly it will respond to the
light that hits it. Remember when we talked about Nipce needing an
eight-hour exposure for his photograph to 'set' and Daguerre
shortened that to a half hour? That would sort of be like Nipce using ISO 25
film and Daguerre using ISO 400 film. Of course, celluloid film is much more
sensitive than that so you don't need ridiculously long exposures, but that
should give you an idea of the difference in films. If you double the film speed
(in ISO units), you can decrease the aperture size by one f-stop or shutter
speed by one click and get an equivalent exposure.
So You would want to buy the fastest film you can get your hands on, right?
Unfortunately, no. The slowest films are made up of much, much smaller
silver-halide crystals. It takes those itty-bitty crystals quite a while
longer to move across the film surface and cluster up where the light is
directing it than faster film, which is made up of larger silver-halide
crystals. The different sized crystals cause something called
'grain'. As a general rule, the faster the film, the larger the
film grain. So the professionals tend to use the slowest films that they can.
Grain tends to get in the way of an image and cause less 'perceived'
sharpness. Grain will be especially apparent on enlargements of photographs
and give the print the appearance of having freckles. Of course, grain can
also be used for effect. High-contrast, black and white images can be made
even more dramatic with a heavy grain, as can gritty subject matter.
|
This
is an image where I used grain to add to the photo, artistically:
This shot was intentionally made as a very bright (referred to as
'high-key'), high-contrast image to showcase the flaming red hair
and tattoo. Below is a close up viewed at 100% magnification showing the
grain in the image. Without the grain, the vast white areas would just seem overexposed
when viewed as a print, but the grain adds a textural feel to the image that
holds it all together.
|
Grain is most often used creatively in black and white photography, because
there are many films that lend themselves nicely to beautiful, fine grain
patterns. It's best to go with a film that will eliminate any grain unless
you have a reason for wanting it there.
|
Here's a chart of sorts to give you an idea of
which films work best for what lighting conditions:
Film Speed
|
Characteristics
|
Advantages
|
Disadvantages
|
ISO 25 - 50
|
As close to flawless as possible, almost impossible to see
grain, even in large enlargements.
|
Beautiful, crystal clear prints with highly saturated colors -
excellent for use in landscape photographs and studio work with controlled
lighting. Pros will recommend nothing else.
|
Difficult to use with moving subjects unless you have bright
light, tripod definitely needed for any low light situations
|
ISO 100 - 200
|
Still a fairly low grain - useful on sunny days or with flash.
|
Good for portraiture under controlled lighting conditions and
outdoor photography.
|
Still normally need a tripod unless light is very bright -
very few advantages over higher quality ISO 25 or 50.
|
ISO 400
|
Most print film manufacturers market this as a versatile,
all-around film to be used under various lighting conditions.
|
Best suited for situations when you dont have any idea what
lighting conditions will be or will be moving from indoors to outdoors and
not have the ability to change film.
|
Quality due to grain becomes a bit of an issue at this point
if you plan on making any enlargements, but still acceptable for snapshots.
|
ISO 800
|
Quite grainy, good for low light situations when flash is not
possible.
|
Very similar to 1000 & 1600 below.
|
Grain visible even in standard sized prints.
|
ISO 1000 - 1600
|
Highly grainy, good for action shots in low light situations
when flash is not possible.
|
Used a lot for situations like basketball games or stage
performances. Can still use reasonable shutter speeds to capture action
under very low light conditions.
|
VERY high grain in shots - this is the reason you see grain in
a lot of indoor sports photography. Its come to be acceptable, even
expected, in those circumstances because its the only film that will
capture such situations.
|
Taking
Care Of Film
Film is very delicate and also very easily damaged. Film is sensitive to all
kinds of things, including X- rays (watch those airports!), chemicals
(including salt if you're in an ocean environment), heat (don't leave your
loaded camera in a car on a hot day), abrasion from rough handling and of
course, light. Film is also susceptible to fungus if kept in high humidity,
which will cause blotches, so be careful of that, too. Film that has gotten
old or been exposed to high temperatures may have an ugly greenish tint or a
mottled appearance. X-rays will cause unsightly lines and impressions in your
developed film. And rough handling will be apparent in spots that show up
looking like cracks, flecks or the actual appearance of the film looking torn
or broken. If you buy film and are going to use it within a couple of weeks,
you can keep it at room temperature. If you stock up and plan on keeping your
film around for a while, however, you should store it in your refrigerator.
Be good to your film and it will be good to you!
|
Types Of Film
Now that you have a general idea of how film works, we can talk about all of
the different types of film.
Negative
Film - Also Called Print Film
If you are looking to wind up with a nice set of prints, this is mostly the
type of film you will use. The film box will usually say something like
'film for color prints'. You take your roll of photographs, then your exposed film will have to be processed by a lab
to create a 'negative'. You've all seen these - the colors are
reversed. The negative is then used to produce a print using the
'positive' colors. A piece of equipment called an enlarger is used
to project the negative image onto light sensitive printing paper. Then in
the last step, that paper itself is processed to give you your print.
One good thing about negative film is that even if you expose it incorrectly,
there is still usually enough detail in the negative that a print can be made
to look just fine. In fact, the machines that printers use today are
'smart' enough that they know if you've exposed your print wrong
and will automatically print it to the exposure it thinks is correct. A handy
thing for that picture of grandma blowing out her birthday candles when the
flash didn't go off, but not at all good for learning photography. You might
think you're exposing your photographs correctly, but the 'smart'
printing machine is actually fixing any mistakes you might be making. You can
be off by two or three f-stops and never even know when you look at your
final prints.
|
Positive
Film - Also Called Slide or Transparency Film
Positive film, as you might expect, is the opposite of negative film. After
processing the film you will have a set of positive images - also called
slides or transparencies. If you want to make a living with photography,
slide film is the only way to go - agencies, editors and print houses will
only accept a print if it is phenomenal and they have no other choice.
Normally they will only take slides (though more and more they are moving
into the world of digital, too - but I'm sticking to just discussing film for
the moment).
We talked about negatives above and how you can vary your exposure and still
get a good print. Slide film is not forgiving in that manner at all - slight
over- or underexposure is nowhere near as tolerable as color negative film.
There are a couple of bonuses to that. Number one: You will definitely learn
how to expose your film properly using slide film, and working the manual
controls on your camera will become so second-nature you won't even have to
think about it. Number two: Color slide film reproduces faithfully and
immediately exactly what you've seen though your viewfinder. There's only one
step - to develop the film. No running through an enlarger onto
light-sensitive paper and then having to develop that paper - no machines
trying to interpret what you might have wanted that image to look like, so
there are way fewer steps in which to screw up your artistic vision.
The other great thing about transparency film is the amazing color saturation
you can get. No print film in the world can match the beautiful colors you
can capture on transparency film specially formulated for landscapes. They
also make special transparency film for portraits and other uses. There are
too many different films for me to discuss specifics here, but a trip to your
camera store to discuss the various professional transparency films that they
stock can be a real eye-opener. I highly recommend test-driving some of these
films - once you've got proper exposure mastered, you'll be amazed at your
results.
|
Black
And White Film
Color negative and transparency film are the two most common types of film,
but one of the most fun films is black and white film. Whereas color film
requires a considerable expense in the materials needed to develop and print
your own images, black and white does not, meaning it gives you the freedom
to do so relatively inexpensively. Without actually having a hands-on class,
I won't go into the details of processing black and white film, but if you
ever get the chance, you should give it a try. Working in a darkroom is great
fun and when you're finished and have that final print in your hands that you
created yourself, it's a very rewarding experience.
|
Infrared Film
I'll touch on a couple more unusual types of film while we're discussing
different kinds. Infrared film has some really unusual characteristics that
can make beautiful effects. While our eyes can't see the infrared portion of
the spectrum, this film can. Human skin and foliage both tend to reflect a LOT of infrared light, so if you use black and white infrared
film to take pictures of either people or landscapes with a lot of green
leaves or grass, you'll get beautiful creamy white tones that almost seem to
have a ghostly glow to them. Skies will turn an inky black while puffy clouds
will stand out brightly. I've seen wedding photographs shot with infrared
film that turned out to be masterpieces, and if you use infrared film for
portraits on someone who happens to have an abundance of blemishes on their
face, you'll get back images where the subject has beautiful, glowing skin -
because the blemishes don't reflect infrared light any differently than the
person's unblemished skin.
A
word of warning, however - shooting infrared is very different than shooting
regular film. Just like our eyes can't see infrared, a camera's light meter
can't see it either, so figuring out the proper exposure can be tricky. Many
photographers use a system of setting the camera's aperture the way they want
it and then using varying shutter speeds, making notes as they go. Then when
you develop your film, you can see which shutter speed worked best and use
that as a rule of thumb. This process is called 'bracketing' your
exposures, and can be handy in any tricky light situation, not just when
using infrared film.
You'll also need a filter for your camera that will filter out all but the
infrared light - there are several to choose from, and I'd suggest a trip to
your local camera shop to discuss the pros and cons of what they might have
available. Another important thing to note is that infrared film must be both
loaded into your camera and removed in absolute darkness or you can ruin your
images.
Infrared has lots of goofy little quirks like that, but having your first
successful prints done with infrared is an exciting and rewarding experience.
It's like seeing a world that you normally wouldn't know existed. Most of the
time the film manufacturer includes specific directions on important facts
you need to know when handling the film, so pay attention to those and you
should be fine.
|
Tungsten-Balanced Film
When we walk outdoors after being inside with artificial light, our eyes
don't perceive much of a difference in the colors of things around us. Film,
however, doesn't have the latitude that our eyes do and it will give your
images very unusual color casts if your lighting is not exactly the specific
'temperature' that the film was created for. Most films are balanced
for natural lighting - daylight.
The Kelvin scale is what is used to measure the temperature of different
types of light. The 'warm', vanilla-colored light that you see at
sunrise, sunset, and in indoors measures between 2000K and 3000K. The
'cool', bluish tinted lighting you see outdoors when it's overcast
measures around 7500K. During the day when the light is bright, it's
considered 'white' and its temperature is about 5000K.
So that means that if you use film balanced for daylight when you're indoors
under tungsten light the color will be incorrectly balanced and the image
will have a yellow or orange color cast. They make tungsten-balanced film to
correct this problem. Likewise, if you then take your tungsten-balanced film
outdoors and try and shoot a landscape, you'll find the opposite, a bluish
color cast.
One of the best uses of tungsten balanced light that I've found is for
photographing Christmas lights during the winter. If you use regular film for
this, a lot of times your photos will come back and those spectacular colors
of the Christmas lights will all come back looking white or yellow. With
tungsten-balanced film, all those marvelous colors will show up as big as
life and you'll get exceptional photographs.
If you're shooting indoors under artificial light, you may want to give
tungsten-balanced color film a try. Negative film is normally
daylight-balanced, but because the printing process automatically adjusts for
color temperature differences, you generally won't notice any odd color cast
when you get your prints back from the lab if you took your pictures indoors.
|
What About Digital Cameras?
Since I know this is an online class and that means many of you are probably
doing work digitally, how does any of this apply to you? If your digital camera
has manual settings, what do those ISO markings mean? You're not using film -
what's the point of having them on a digital camera?
You're right, digital cameras don't use film. They have image sensors that
work in place of film. That ISO marking means that the camera will set it's little computer to work as if it had that type of
film in it, making that number it's ISO equivalent. Just like film having
larger grain with the faster ISOs, using a faster ISO in your digital camera
will give you a 'noisier' image. Noise is sort of the digital
equivalent of grain. Just like film, you'll get the best image quality when
you use your lowest ISO settings available. This will require longer
exposures, so a tripod might be necessary.
|
|
Photo taken at ISO 400 on my digital camera, viewed at 100%
magnification. Notice the severe noise in the dark corner of the image.
|
Same photo taken at ISO 50 on my digital camera, viewed at
100% magnification. Big difference!
|
Okay, so what about all that light and color temperature stuff?
If you have a DSLR camera or other professional camera that has the
capability of taking photographs in RAW format, you can always go in and
change the white balance or exposure after you've taken your photographs.
When you take a photograph in RAW format, your image sensor records it just like
it sees it and doesn't add ANY sort of white balance to the shot and when you
upload it to your computer, you can then go in and make all sort of
incremental adjustments until the shot is just right. I shoot almost
exclusively in RAW format with my digital camera.
If you don't have a camera that will let you take photos in RAW format, your
camera probably comes with settings you can use for daylight, cloudy,
incandescent, fluorescent and other types of lighting, depending on the
camera. You can also use your camera's auto white balance, but beware - if
the camera guesses wrong and you need to go in and make changes using
photo-editing software, image quality degrades as you make changes to your
picture. It's best to always set your white balance manually if you can.
|
Onward to our assignments:
Assignment
1:
Assignment 1: Using a film camera, take both a roll of slide film and a
roll of negative film. Use the bracketing system to take a couple of sets
of shots that are:
2 stops underexposed
1 stop underexposed
Normal exposure
1 stop overexposed
2 stops overexposed
Assignment
2:
Take notes on what your aperture, shutter speed and film speeds are set to
on your camera so that you can compare when you get your developed film
back. When you do get them, you'll be amazed. Most likely you won't be able
to tell much difference in the negative film that has been printed, but the
slides will show a dramatic difference. Even if you don't shoot much film,
this is an excellent exercise in helping you understand exposure more in
depth than you do already. Compare the difference in color between the
correctly exposed slides and prints. Since these are not digital, unless
you have access to a scanner, you won't be able to post your results, but
please post any relevant comments you might have.
Assignment
3:
Take a white subject and photograph it both inside
and outside, in both bright light and dim light, using your camera's auto
white balance. This is a good way to see how accurate your camera's white
balance actually is - are the whites really white? If so, great! Next, if
you have preset white balances on your camera, set the same white object up
on a white or black background and take pictures of it using each setting -
sunny, cloudy, incandescent, fluorescent. This
will give you some idea of the differences in color temperature your camera
sees that your eye might not naturally notice.
|
|